|
You’ve heard it before: plain language is essential to effective regulatory communication. I have
discussed this topic many times—writing that avoids jargon, long sentences, and convoluted phrasing improves readability. But here is the problem: plain language does not always help the reader understand what matters—or what to do with the information. A sentence may be grammatically simple, technically correct, and jargon-free—and still be useless to a regulatory reviewer or clinical research manager trying to make a decision. Clarity is not just about words. It is about what those words are doing. That is, the action of meaning. Action of meaning refers to how writing should do more than just state facts. The action within writing is shaping how facts are understood. The approach involves selecting, organizing, and connecting information so that the reader grasps why it matters. In regulatory writing, the action is to turn data into insight and support decision-making. Plain language is necessary—but not sufficient. To achieve true clarity in regulatory documents—especially those designed to inform regulatory judgment—we need more. We need writing actions: carefully orchestrated rhetorical moves that position, prioritize, and connect information with intent. What Are Writing Actions? Writing actions are deliberate moves that shape how information is delivered. Each action—such as previewing, overviewing, summarizing, and synthesizing—serves a distinct purpose, helping the reader understand what’s being said, why it matters, and how to act on it. These actions give structure and direction to plain language text. The actions guide attention and support decisions. What Plain Language Does Well When done well, plain language:
Where Plain Language Falls Short Even a well-written sentence can feel out of place if it does not:
In the book I co-wrote with Stephen Bernhardt --Writing for the Biopharmaceutical Regulatory Reader (2nd Edition)—we dedicate over 60 pages to discussing 11 writing actions. We consider these actions to be the rhetorical moves that turn information into insight. Four Writing Actions That Boost Clarity 1. Preview Previewing sets expectations. The writing action is a “framing” technique. The action positions the reader to absorb the information with the proper context and connect it to the larger purpose of the document. Example: This section evaluates the safety profile of the investigational monoclonal antibody using pooled data from five 26-week studies conducted in North America, Europe, and East Asia. The focus is on treatment-emergent adverse events, serious infections, and discontinuations. Data from subgroups—by age, comorbidity, and prior biologic use—are also included to support regulatory interpretation of risk across diverse patient populations. Why it works:
review team. Example: This document discusses the relevant data from individual studies leading to the approvals of nivolumab and pembrolizumab for the first-line treatment of unresectable or metastatic HER2-negative gastric adenocarcinoma as well as the data submitted to support approval of tislelizumab for the same indication. The aggregated experience with these independent trials and products provides a framework to discuss the strength of evidence for PD-L1 expression as a predictive biomarker for patient selection in this patient population, differing risk-benefit assessments in different subpopulations defined by PD-L1 expression, and adequacy of the cumulative data to restrict the approvals of immune checkpoint inhibitors based on PD-L1 expression. Why it works:
2. Overview Overviews are selective, not comprehensive. Overviews highlight the most important ideas in a document, section, or dataset. The writing action is to orient the reader to the "So what did we learn?" message or key findings. Overviews often use interpretive language that signals importance but defers delivery of precise numerical support to later sections of the document. Example: The clinical trials have demonstrated DTG’s antiretroviral activity and safety in various settings. Key safety observations include:
structure of the content that follows. Summaries come later—they distill key details after the content has been presented. 3. Summary and Synthesis: Writing Actions That Inform If preview and overview frame, then summary and synthesis inform. These writing actions appear after data presentation to help the reader interpret and apply what they have just consumed. Summary distills the most important details. A summary does not repeat the data—it distills and prioritizes. Summaries help readers confirm “So what?” messages, locate key conclusions, and prepare for comparison across family or families of data. Synthesis goes further. This writing action is all about connection. The writing action links evidence across trials, endpoints, or populations—identifying relationships, patterns, and meaning. Synthesis is essential when articulating benefit-risk tradeoffs, justifying dose, or drawing conclusions across complex data sets. Together, these actions help readers move from detail to decision. Summarizing and synthesizing are not reporting—the actions are to distill and contextualize. Final Word: Activate Plain Language with Purpose Plain language improves reader access, but writing actions give meaning and direction to language. Preview and overview frame expectations and focus attention. Summary and synthesis inform the reader—distilling evidence, revealing connections, and guiding decisions. Together, these writing actions coupled with plain language writing make regulatory documents clearer, faster to navigate, and more useful to those who must act on them. Clarity in regulatory writing is not only about managing paragraphs, sentences, and words. It is about activating them with purpose. That is, enabling the action of meaning.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorGregory Cuppan is the Managing Principal of McCulley/Cuppan Inc., a group he co-founded. Mr. Cuppan has spent 30+ years working in the life sciences with 20+ years providing consulting and training services to pharmaceutical and medical device companies and other life science enterprises. Archives
November 2025
Categories |
RSS Feed